Verbal Agreements – Are They Binding?

A verbal agreement can sometimes become expensive disputes. When it comes to agreements about land and home ownership, Ontario’s Statute of Frauds requires agreements to be documented in writing and signed by the parties to be enforceable.  However, courts may recognize certain unwritten arrangements as discussed in this newsletter.

In Jeffrey v. Jeffrey (2026), parents transferred their home to their son on the understanding that they could live there rent-free for life. When their son died, their right to remain on the property was disputed. The court upheld the arrangement through “part performance”, an equitable doctrine that looks to the conduct of the parties. First, the parents had transferred ownership without receiving the fair market value for their home. Second, everyone acted as if the agreement was binding, and so the history of rent-free living was used in the parent’s defence despite the missing paperwork.

In Burbidge v. Casullo (2023), a condominium owner transferred title under a verbal arrangement. Although the oral agreement failed the written requirements of the Statute of Frauds, the court found other grounds to protect the original owner, finding a resulting trust and constructive trust. The evidence demonstrated that the original owner always acted as if the property would be returned and continued to pay related debts on the home.

The lesson is that while a verbal promise may have legal protection in some situations, proving ownership without written legal contracts can sometimes require costly litigation. Before transferring ownership, contributing money or promising someone a lifelong home, get legal advice and document the arrangement. A clear agreement can protect your investment, preserve family relationships and explain what happens if someone dies or circumstances change.

Considering a property arrangement with family or friends? Call Liddiard Law at (905) 932-5437 to schedule a consultation before making any promises.